What Methods Would Allow For More Efficient Management Of Intermittent Renewable Energy Sources?

Intermittent renewable energy sources like wind and solar power generate electricity inconsistently due to their reliance on weather conditions. Efficient management of these variable resources is crucial as renewable energy grows as a share of the overall energy mix. Handling the variability and uncertainty of renewables requires new approaches and technologies to balance supply and demand (Intermittent Renewable Energy). Without proper management, the intermittency of renewables can lead to energy waste, grid instability, and continued reliance on fossil fuel backups (Renewable Energy Storage Solutions: Overcoming Intermittency Challenges). As renewables supply more of our energy, overcoming their intermittent nature through methods like storage, forecasting and smart grids will be key to building a clean and reliable energy system.

Table of Contents

Energy Storage

Energy storage systems are vital for enabling higher adoption of renewable energy sources like solar and wind which have intermittent availability. Several promising solutions for large-scale energy storage exist:

Batteries – Lithium-ion batteries have become a popular option for short-term storage. Large battery installations like the Tesla Powerpack can store hundreds of megawatt-hours.
Pumped hydro – Water is pumped uphill into reservoirs during times of excess renewable generation and released to drive hydro turbines when renewable output is low. Established technology with high storage capacity.
Compressed air – Air is compressed and stored under pressure in underground caverns. The high-pressure air can be heated and expanded through turbines to generate electricity when needed.

Flywheels – Rotating cylinders store kinetic energy during charging. The flywheel’s momentum can generate electricity during discharge.

Energy storage provides a buffer that allows the grid to cope with fluctuations in renewable output. With sufficient storage capacity, renewables can potentially meet a higher portion of overall demand. However, adding large-scale storage substantially increases costs.

Geographic Diversity

Spreading wind and solar farms over large geographic areas can help smooth out the intermittency issues associated with renewable energy sources. As noted by Scientific American, the law of large numbers means that as more diverse renewable energy generators are connected over larger geographic regions, their combined power generation becomes more stable and predictable. Research by Mills (2010) found that disaggregating wind and solar output to finer geographic resolutions substantially reduces hour-to-hour and day-to-day variability in aggregate power generation (Mills, 2010). Another study by Simoes et al. (2017) showed that greater geographic disaggregation of solar PV and wind power plants significantly reduced output variability over different timescales (Simoes et al., 2017). Overall, spreading out renewable energy facilities over broader geographic areas helps smooth their intermittent output.

Overbuilding Capacity

One method to manage the variability of renewable energy generation is to build extra renewable capacity beyond what is needed to meet average demand. This overbuilding of capacity provides a buffer to account for times when renewable output is low due to weather conditions or time of day.

According to a 2023 study published in ScienceDirect, Australia’s excellent solar resources make it a prime candidate for exploring overbuilding of renewable capacity. The study states that “overbuilding wind and solar capacity can mitigate renewable intermittency at low cost.”

However, overbuilding does come with added expense for infrastructure and land use. Careful analysis is needed to find the optimal level of overcapacity before costs outweigh benefits. The study suggests 100-150% overbuilding can balance affordability and reliability.

Overall, strategic overbuilding of renewable generation can provide firm capacity to offset intermittency. When combined with other grid management strategies, it offers a viable path for high penetrations of renewable energy on the grid. (Rey-Costa, 2023)

Forecasting

Improved weather forecasting will better predict renewable output and facilitate grid integration of intermittent sources like wind and solar. Accurate forecasting of renewable generation allows grid operators to plan ahead and adjust other energy sources to account for variability.

New forecasting techniques like machine learning and statistical models can enhance prediction accuracy over traditional methods. For example, deep learning models using neural networks have shown strong performance for short-term forecasting of solar and wind power (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0959652622049885). Integrated systems that combine adaptive algorithms, decomposition, and neural networks can provide robust forecasts across different time horizons (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36640232/).

While no model is perfect, advanced forecasting methods allow grid operators to better manage the variability of renewables. Improving renewable forecasting will be key for grid stability as more intermittent sources come online.

Demand Response

Demand response involves adjusting energy usage to better align with the availability of renewable energy generation sources like wind and solar power (https://energy5.com/the-symbiotic-relationship-how-demand-response-supports-renewable-energy). This helps to balance supply and demand, integrating higher levels of renewables onto the grid. Demand response programs incentivize users to shift their electricity consumption and curb demand during times of peak renewable energy production.

Studies show that implementing demand response significantly increases renewable energy adoption. The technology provides the grid flexibility needed to rely more on variable green resources (https://energy5.com/the-role-of-demand-response-in-promoting-renewable-energy-adoption). Through real-time communication and control systems, demand response enables better grid integration of renewables at scale.

Research also finds positive synergies and co-benefits between demand response and renewable energy policies. Implementing both together enhances cost-effectiveness and reduces greenhouse gas emissions more than either policy individually (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032122008176). Demand response is a critical grid management tool for transitioning to higher renewable energy penetration.

Smart Grids

Smart grid technology can help better integrate renewable energy sources like wind and solar into the electric grid by balancing supply and demand Smart Grids for renewable Energy Integration. Smart grids utilize advanced metering, monitoring sensors, and automated controls to respond in real-time to fluctuations in renewable energy generation. For example, smart inverters can rapidly adjust the amount of power being fed into the grid based on cloud coverage for solar or wind speed for wind turbines.

With smart grid technology, grid operators have enhanced visibility into energy supply and demand. This allows them to call on demand response resources during times of oversupply to avoid curtailing renewable generation, as well as manage charging of electric vehicles and energy storage to absorb excess renewable energy production Digital Solutions Paving the Way for Sustainable Energy Practices. Smart grids also facilitate better coordination of diverse renewable resources across wider geographic areas to minimize variability.

Energy Markets

One method to help integrate intermittent renewables is to develop more sophisticated energy markets. Dynamic pricing that reflects real-time conditions can incentivize consumers to shift demand and better align it with renewable generation. For example, Ariel Liebman notes that time-of-use pricing that charges higher rates during peak times can motivate load shifting to off-peak periods when more renewables are online.

Advanced forecasting tools, like those offered by Energy Exemplar’s Aurora software, can also help predict renewable output and inform pricing and bidding strategies on energy markets. By improving the accuracy of forecasts, grid operators and utilities can better plan the utilization of renewable assets. Overall, more dynamic, sophisticated energy markets can unlock more flexibility in the system to cost-effectively integrate intermittent renewables.

Curtailment

One way to help manage the variability of renewable energy generation is through curtailment. Curtailment refers to limiting or stopping the output of renewable energy sources like wind and solar during periods when supply exceeds demand on the grid. There are two main reasons curtailment occurs: system-wide oversupply and local transmission constraints.

System-wide oversupply happens when the total renewable generation being fed into the grid is higher than the total demand at that time. This can occur during periods of high renewable output, like a sunny or windy day, coupled with low energy demand. To avoid stability issues on the grid from over-generation, grid operators may curtail some renewable output. Curtailing during oversupply helps balance the grid until demand increases or generation decreases.

Local transmission constraints cause curtailment when there is insufficient transmission capacity to export all the renewable generation in a local area out to the wider grid. Congestion on transmission lines can force curtailment of local renewable sources until additional transmission capacity is added. Strategically planned transmission expansion can help minimize curtailment from local congestion issues.

While curtailment results in lost renewable output, it is an important and low-cost flexibility option to balance supply and demand on grids with high renewable penetration. Reducing curtailment requires enabling greater system flexibility on both the supply and demand sides.(1)

Conclusion

In summary, there are several methods that can enable more efficient management of intermittent renewable energy sources. Energy storage through batteries and other technologies allows renewable energy to be stored when supply exceeds demand and utilized when needed. Geographic diversity of renewable generation helps smooth out variability and avoid correlated lulls in renewable output. Overbuilding renewable capacity ensures excess supply even during periods of low renewable production. Accurate forecasting of renewable generation improves grid management. Demand response shifts demand to match renewable generation. Smart grids use advanced ICT to balance supply and demand. Energy markets provide incentives to balance supply and demand. Curtailment of renewable generation can be used when needed to maintain grid stability.

Looking ahead, continuing advances in storage, forecasting, and grid technology will further improve renewable integration and enable high levels of renewable penetration. Policy support remains important to provide incentives for adoption of enabling technologies and practices. With the right methods and technologies, a grid powered predominantly by renewable energy is achievable in the coming decades.